Case study 1 · Overtime income

Three lenders said no because of overtime history

A new-construction buyer was declined by three lenders over 1 year and 4 months of overtime history. Sarah reviewed it without the same lender overlays, and the loan closed in about two weeks.

ClosedTold by Sarah Baraz · Mortgage Loan Officer · NMLS #1859224 · Team Baraz / CMG Home Loans

The situation

A buyer had been preapproved by Sarah and then went under contract on a new-construction home. The builder referred him to its preferred lender and to two other lenders.

What went wrong

All three lenders declined the buyer. He worked full time and also earned overtime, but his overtime history was only 1 year and 4 months.

Sarah explained that the other lenders had overlays affecting their ability to use the overtime. An overlay is an extra rule a lender adds on top of the loan program's own guidelines.

What Sarah did

After the buyer called Sarah again, she revisited the loan under the guidelines available through her lending channel, without the same overlays.

The result

Sarah reported that the team completed the financing and closed in approximately two weeks.

The lesson: A denial related to variable-income history is not always the same thing as a universal program prohibition. Review the applicable guidelines and any lender-specific overlays.

Facing something similar?

A denial, a shaky preapproval or a tricky income question is a reason to get a second look, ideally before you sign a contract. Send Sarah your scenario.

Send your scenario to Sarah See all case studies

Examples are anonymized and provided for educational purposes. They follow Sarah's own accounts; no names, addresses or dollar amounts are included. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Loan approval depends on the individual borrower, property, documentation, program guidelines and underwriting review. This is not a commitment to lend. Sarah Baraz is based in San Antonio and licensed in Texas, Florida and California.